All Things Fine Art
WHY DO I HAVE TO BE CONSISTENT?

"Me and My Shadow", 11x14", oil on canvas panel
Galleries prefer to represent artists whose body of works are recognizably their own. Deviations from the norm in a body of work are unwelcome. A tidier package of paintings with a recognizable style is easier to sell. So, where does this leave artists who are a bit wobbley in style consistency? I’ve always admired artists whose work is consistently “theirs”. I think it would be wonderful to have a set process and outcome with every painting that say’s “this is me”. Unfortunately, that is NOT me!
As I look around my studio/gallery I can see why folks say they can always recognize my work. The paintings I show to the public have a certain consistency in style and subject. In reality, folks might not recognize all of my work, in fact they might think some paintings were created by another artist all together. “Me and My Shadow” above is a typical painting of mine that has my recognizable signature style. But, look at “Carmen in the Lilies” and the unfinished still life below. One painting is very formal and precisely rendered and the other loosely casual.
Yes, these paintings are also mine.

"Carmen in the Lilies", 8x8", oil on canvas panel
Every once in awhile I have an urge to either tighten way up in my painting or get creatively loose with the brush. For me, that is one of the joys of painting, i.e.: doing a painting just for yourself sometimes and not worrying about whether it will please the galleries. Working this way gets my creative juices excited.
I read the advice of an art teacher one time that recommended after every five paintings created for the galleries that you should paint one for yourself. That’s really excellent advice. It keeps you on the edge creatively and eliminates the possibility of developing that “stamped” look in your work. Many of those “for me” paintings end up never being finished and most certainly, not even shown other than in my own studio. I have the joy of starting them, accomplishing what creatively got me going and when satisfied, moving on to other things.
“Carmen in the Lilies” is a plein air painting that was quickly done on a very hot and muggy day. It was my second painting of the morning and very simply I was tired, wanted only to capture the idea of one of my painting buddies enjoying herself in the flowers. I was not interested at all in defining anything other than giving the figure a few hard edges. I was satisfied with this painting and it apparently was attractive to others on Facebook and several collectors who inquired about it. It sold within a short time of being painted.
The unfinished still life was painted in an entirely different situation. For personal reasons, I had been unable to paint for some time and had a lot of time to study. I decided to study the works of David Laffel and reread quite a bit about Rembrandt. I’ve never cared for dark paintings and therefore, I’ve never been too much interested in either of these masters and their works since I consider much of what they’ve created to be dark (I have a very strong dislike of dark backgrounds). I thought perhaps I was missing something. Therein was my challenge. Once I was able to paint again, I decided to do one for me by creating a still life in tight realism (tight for me) and contrasting my light struck subject against a dark background.
Untitled Still Life
The idea of doing this painting also came at a time when I wanted to experiment with water based oil paints. I’d used Winsor/Newton’s Artisans paints long ago and decided to dig them out and use them for this painting. I learned a lot during the painting of this still life. It certainly reinforced my dislike for dark backgrounds, got the urge to be precise out of my system and convinced me that I don’t like working with Artisan paints as they are too stiff and have a gummy consistency. As you can see, I got out of this painting what I wanted and the result is….it will never be finished.
The bottom line on these paintings, as far as galleries go is this. Of the three, only “Me and My Shadow” represents my larger body of works, i.e.: my signature style, etc. Of the three, this is the one that may go to a gallery while the others will not. Does that mean that “Carmen in the Lilies” is not a good painting? Absolutely not, It is fresh, and spontaneous and captures the moment of the day. It’s a great little painting (little in that it is only 8x8”) and can stand on its own merit. It’s simply not one that the galleries would choose as it doesn’t “fit” their concept of my recognizable style. They prefer my more consistent style as an easier package to sell to their clients. If I had their job, most likely I’d be of the same mind. However, between you and me, I’m glad I’m not in their shoes. I prefer to be right where I am, i.e. being somewhat consistent (this is what pays the bills) and enjoying the extremes of creativity from time to time. Isn’t that what art is all about?
See more paintings at www.SGTarr.com
2 Responses to WHY DO I HAVE TO BE CONSISTENT?
Leave a Comment